I think that might just make the award less prestigious - I like the one only. Be interesting to hear what others think though.

I like the idea of one COC - I have always been very proud to receive a COC award xx

I agree with both of you, above. If you have more than one, it becomes less of a win.

I often award the COC to multiple members while the challenge is running so that multiple members have a chance for their page to be on the front page of the challenge. Then when the challenge is over I will either award the 4th place page or my favorite page that maybe did not get as many points the COC. I agree. It is not as special if there is more than one.

I like to highlight lots of different pages as COC when running a challenge too and then I usually choose one that did not place in the top 3 to make sure 4 different pages are given awards. It is definitely tough sometimes but highlighting the pages throughout the challenge helps get exposure for different entries too.

You're all right. It does make it difficult, but it also makes it more special for there to be just one COC.