Author gypsykate says: I have decided to retain a couple of scraps even if the tip journaling is not IN the scrapbook as required. i retained them coz some people might still be able to learn something from the journaling in the page descriptions. however, i will have to remove them if they look like they could win - i hope it's understood that i can't allow them to win as they did not satisfy the challenge requirements completely. i hope you find this a fair decision. hugs - kate Jan 7, 2008